Strengthening Sustainability Efforts by Reducing or Eliminating the Use of Chemicals in Palm Oil Mill Boiler Feedwater Treatment

A lot of palm oil companies now have sustainability certificates, such as ISPO (Indonesian Sustainable Palm Oil) and RSPO (Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil). To market palm oil and its derivatives to Europe, the European Union has implemented the EUDR, or European Union Anti-Deforestation Regulation. This regulation requires every business actor to prove that their palm oil does not originate from deforested land after the deadline of December 31, 2020. The EUDR itself will be implemented on December 30, 2026, for large and medium-sized companies. Sustainability certifications such as ISPO and RSPO are not the same as EUDR compliance, but they complement each other. This is because ISPO or RSPO serve as important tools to strengthen traceability and due diligence to comply with the EU's anti-deforestation regulations. Once certified, ISPO or RSPO simply add detailed spatial geolocation data to fully comply with the EUDR standard.

As the decarbonization trend continues to penetrate various sectors of life, various efforts aligned and relevant to decarbonization and aspirations will become a concern, even an option, and even an obligation. Sooner or later, these climate-smart efforts will become increasingly accepted and become an integral part of human life. For example, the palm oil industry is currently moving towards the use of electric vehicles in the plantation sector. The use of electric vehicles has the potential to provide added value, especially for companies that have obtained sustainability certifications such as the RSPO and ISPO. The use of electric vehicles allows palm oil companies to claim reduced fossil fuel use and reap sustainability benefits.

Another example is the use of organic fertilizers or biofertilizers. The use of biofertilizers or organic fertilizers can have several positive effects on environmental sustainability, as they can reduce the use of chemical fertilizers by up to 25%. This effort not only reduces environmental pollution and health risks but also enriches biodiversity and supports climate-smart agriculture. In an era where sustainability is a focus and a "selling point" for products (especially in Europe), this effort is very effective. This is especially true given the intense competition from other vegetable oils, such as soybean oil and sunflower seed oil.

This is also closely aligned with water treatment, particularly boiler feedwater treatment, which uses less or no chemicals. This also reduces environmental pollution and health risks. Boilers can be considered the "heart" of palm oil mills, converting water into high-pressure steam to power the production process and generate electricity for the mill and its employee housing. Like all production equipment, boilers have a lifespan. When a boiler's lifespan is exceeded, it is not only uneconomical due to high maintenance and operational costs but also dangerous. Good and well-maintained water quality will ensure the boiler's lifespan meets or even exceeds standards.

The average lifespan, which is the technical and economic life of a palm oil mill boiler, is 20 years, and by maintaining water quality, it is expected to be 20% longer, to 24 years. In addition to the technical and environmental benefits, there are also economic benefits. A palm oil mill with a capacity of 45 tons of fresh fruit bunches (FFB) per hour using electrochemical technology will achieve an estimated annual savings of over 250 million rupiah. For more detailed information, please contact us. Currently, according to data from the Indonesian Ministry of Agriculture, the number of palm oil mills in Indonesia is recorded at around 1,200 to 1,500. This is understandable, considering the increasing area of ​​oil palm plantations, currently reaching nearly 17 million hectares, thus increasing the need for palm oil mills.

Why make calculations or simulations for a palm oil mill with a capacity of 45 tons of fresh fruit bunches (FFB)/hour? This is because this capacity is the average capacity of palm oil mills in Indonesia. For example, one of the largest palm oil companies, PT Astra Agro Lestari (AALI), has 32 palm oil mills with a total capacity of 1,570 tons of fresh fruit bunches (FFB) /hour, or an average of 49 tons of FFB /hour, which is close to a capacity of 45 tons of FFB /hour. And with the number of mills in Indonesia, say 1,500 units and each mill can save 250 million rupiah/year, there will be an estimated savings of 375 billion rupiah per year from this boiler feed water treatment, in addition to technical and environmental benefits, especially to strengthen sustainability efforts to meet EUDR requirements.

Environmentally Friendly Boiler Feedwater Treatment in Palm Oil Mills & More in Line with Sustainability Missions

As the decarbonization trend continues to penetrate various sectors of life, various efforts aligned and relevant to decarbonization and aspirations will become a concern, even a choice, and even an obligation. Sooner or later, these climate-smart efforts will become increasingly accepted and an integral part of human life. The upstream palm oil industry (particularly palm oil mills/CPO mills) is no exception. With the use of biomass fuel for boiler operations, which outputs high-pressure steam for palm oil mill operations and electricity production, from a climate perspective, the palm oil industry contributes approximately 1.4% of carbon emissions to the atmosphere.

Emissions from the palm oil industry primarily come from carbon loss during land clearing/deforestation, emissions from peat drainage, and emissions from palm oil mill effluent (POME). In addition, there are also emissions from the use of vehicles for transporting raw materials and palm oil products, as well as for plantation operations (soil cultivation, fertilization, harvesting, etc.), and during palm oil mill start-up. Compared to other sectors, such as energy, power generation is the largest global contributor of emissions at 29%, followed by industry (cement, steel, chemical, etc.) at 21%, and transportation (land, sea, and air) at 15%. Although the global palm oil industry is quantitatively small at 1.4%, in the NZE (Net Zero Emission) effort, it must still be reduced.

This also includes the water treatment sector. In palm oil mills/CPO mills, where steam generated from boilers is used not only for electricity generation but also for mill operations, water treatment, especially for boiler feedwater (BFW), is crucial. Water is likened to blood for the human body. Environmentally friendly water treatment, without secondary pollution and without chemicals, is predicted to become a new trend in this era of decarbonization and sustainability. The high water quality specifications required for boiler feedwater (BFW) require a series of water treatment unit operations. In addition to being clean and clear (TDS <700 ppm), it must also have low hardness, mineral content, and oxygen content.

A number of equipment such as ion exchangers, activated carbon filters, RO membranes, and deaerators are used to produce boiler feedwater (BFW). For an environmentally friendly water treatment process that is more in line with the sustainability mission, the electrochemical method is the solution. By using the principle of redox reactions (reduction and oxidation), electrochemical cells will produce ions capable of sterilization, deodorization, scale prevention, rust protection, decomposition of organic compounds that are not easily biodegradable, remove heavy metal ions, remove residual chlorine, remove residual insecticides, and so on. The use of this method will also save or extend the service life of ion exchangers, activated carbon filters, and especially the RO membrane.

This not only provides environmental and sustainability benefits but also economic benefits. Technical and economic comparisons can also be made between conventional and chemical methods and this electrochemical method. Please contact us if you'd like to make such a comparison, and we'll create a simulation. Besides the longer lifespan of boiler feedwater treatment equipment, which requires less frequent cleaning, another important piece of equipment that can be saved or extended is the boiler. Boilers, which have a lifespan of around 15-20 years, can also last 30% or even more, depending on a number of factors, including water conditions.

Related to decarbonization and sustainability, the palm oil industry is also currently moving towards electric vehicles in the plantation sector. The use of electric vehicles has the potential to provide added value, especially for companies that have obtained sustainability certifications such as the RSPO (Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil) and ISPO (Indonesia Sustainable Palm Oil). The use of electric vehicles allows palm oil companies to claim fossil fuel reduction and benefit from sustainability aspects. Technically, when charging the electric vehicle's battery, it comes from renewable energy sources, namely electricity produced by palm oil mills that use biomass fuel (fiber and palm kernel shells) as their energy source, and not from PLN (Indonesia state owned company electricity) , which uses fossil fuels like coal. 

Not Only Reduce Steam Cost, but Also Reduce Water Treatment Cost for Boiler Feed Water and Even Also Increase Revenue with EFB Cogeneration

Even though biomass waste is abundant in palm oil mills, the use of efficient boilers is also needed. Efficient use of biomass waste according to the type/specifications will also provide additional benefits for palm oil mills. The longer the biomass waste, the more diverse its uses, ideally even zero waste. Apart from mesocarp fiber which is usually used 100% and added with a number of palm kernel shells (PKS) and sometimes also a few empty palm fruit bunches (EFB), an efficient boiler will optimize the type and amount of biomass. For example, PKS as a commodity that can be sold are used as little as possible for boiler fuel, so that more can be sold which increases the profits of the palm oil mill.

Photo taken from here

Is a utility business like buying steam from another company needed? Utility businesses like selling steam, heat, or electricity are indeed starting to emerge; for more details, read here. Certain companies are greatly helped and receive utility products according to their wishes. They do not want the hassle of operating a boiler, including sourcing its fuel. However, for palm oil mills that in their operations produce a lot of biomass waste that can be used as fuel, it is more practical and efficient to operate their own boiler. And this has been a common practice in palm oil mills for a long time. Therefore, cooperating with a utility company to obtain steam and electricity is not an effective solution. The effective solution is the use of an efficient boiler as explained above.

Apart from that, regarding boiler feed water to increase efficiency or reduce costs and be environmentally friendly, AOP (Advanced Oxidation Process) technology, namely an electrochemical device, is used. With this method, apart from not using chemicals so it is environmentally friendly, it will also increase the service life of the RO (reverse osmosis) membrane which is the heart of the water treatment unit. Not only will the RO membrane have a longer service life, but also the activated carbon filter and ion exchange resin, which are stages of water treatment. Apart from being environmentally friendly, this technology is also more in line with the sustainability mission.

And regarding boiler operations, even to increase the volume of PKS that can be sold, cogeneration of empty palm fruit bunches (EFB) can be carried out. In this way, the EFB, which have been waste biomass which pollutes the environment and which most palm oil mills have not yet processed, are then burned to produce heat and potassium ash. The potassium content above 30% in the ash will make quality fertilizer that can be sold or used in your own plantation. Meanwhile, the heat from burning EFB is used as additional energy for the boiler (cogeneration). In this way, 100% of PKS can be sold and even exported.

If the use of PKS for boiler fuel reaches 50% then using this technology means that 50% of the  PKS can be recovered or taken back or 100% of the PKS can be sold or even exported. For example, a palm oil mill under normal conditions can sell 2,000 tons of PKS/month, then by using this technology the palm oil mill can sell 4,000 tons of PKS/month. Of course the increase in PKS supply volume is very significant to increase income, for more details read here. 

OPT Briquette and EFB Briquette for Medium Capacity Industrial Biomass Boiler Consumption

The growing utility business, specifically the provision of steam and electricity for renewable energy-based industries, particularly biomass, has led to a growing need for biomass fuel. This also applies to industries using their utility units to produce steam and electricity using biomass fuel. In addition to biomass fuel, water quality, the raw material for steam and electricity production (using steam turbines), is also crucial and must be considered. Good water quality will ensure optimum steam and electricity production performance, and the longevity of equipment (boilers, heat exchangers, steam turbines, and cooling towers), and vice versa. Good water quality is like healthy blood for our bodies, enabling all organs to function optimally.

Palm oil industry solid waste is a potential raw material for biomass fuel. This solid waste is empty fruit bunches (EFB) and oil palm trunks (OPT). EFB is produced from palm oil mill operations with a percentage of approximately 22% of fresh fruit bunches (FFB), while oil palm trunk waste is produced from replanting programs of oil palm plantations, which are also very abundant. For more details, read here. Utilizing both of these biomass wastes for the production of biomass fuel, especially biomass briquettes, would be very good. But why are they processed into briquettes?

The advantage of briquettes over pellets, aside from technical advantages, lies in their scale. Briquette production requires a looser particle size and lower moisture content. Energy consumption per ton of briquette production is also lower than that of pellet production. This makes EFB briquette and OPT briquette production more suitable for a palm oil mill serving medium-sized industries. A palm oil mill with a capacity of 45 tons/hour of FFB will produce approximately 10 tons/hour of EFB. With a 20-hour daily operation, approximately 200 tons will be produced per day. With a moisture content of approximately 60%, this means that after drying, approximately 100 tons/day (10% moisture content) will be produced, or 2,500 tons/month.

Likewise, when using oil palm trunk (OPT) waste as raw material, it depends on the ratio or percentage of land replanted each year. Replanting itself is an effort to continuously maintain the productivity of the oil palm plantation itself, in addition to the use of superior seeds and intensification. For more details, read here. For example, with a land area of ​​10,000 hectares and each year replanting 5% of the land, or 500 hectares. With an average of 125 trees per hectare of oil palm plantation and each tree having an average dry weight of 0.4 tons, then per hectare obtained 50 tons of dry weight of biomass. With an area of ​​500 hectares, this means 25,000 dry palm trunk biomass (10% moisture content) each year or can be processed into OPT briquettes with a capacity of around 2,000 tons/month.

Biomass boilers, used for producing biomass briquettes (EFB briquettes/OPT briquettes), can utilize various combustion technologies, such as moving grates, stokers, reciprocating grates, and so on. The choice depends on the cost or price of the boiler and its efficiency. In addition to biomass fuel, to align with decarbonization and sustainability programs, water for boiler operation, including boiler feedwater and cooling water for heat exchangers (heat exchangers/condensers), is crucial. This is likened to blood for the human body; healthy blood ensures optimal function. If impure blood circulates throughout the body, for example due to kidney failure, organs will automatically be damaged, and a person will soon die.

To maintain water quality for steam production through a boiler, boiler feedwater/demin water must strictly comply with the boiler's operational specifications. The higher the boiler pressure, the higher the water quality or purer the water required. If the steam is used for electricity production, after the steam drives the turbine, it needs to be condensed in a heat exchanger (condenser) so that it changes phase back to liquid and enters the boiler again. This heat exchanger requires cooling water that is continuously used repeatedly, thus requiring a cooling tower. Not only does the boiler feedwater/demin water need to meet the required technical specifications, but so does the cooling water for this condenser. With water volumes circulating up to thousands of tons per hour and operating 24 hours a day (the same as boiler operations) in the cooling tower, a number of water problems in the cooling tower need to be addressed effectively and efficiently. A number of water problems that occur in cooling towers can be read here.

In addition to electricity production, steam is also used for processes within a specific plant. If the steam is then condensed, then liquid, and returned to the boiler, this requires a cooling tower, just as in electricity production. Efficient and environmentally friendly water treatment technology, which eliminates secondary pollution and is easy to operate and maintain, aligns with the vision of decarbonization and sustainability. This vision of decarbonization and sustainability will be even more optimal or ideal for utility units, namely the use of biomass-based renewable energy and environmentally friendly water treatment technology. 

Utility Business for Palm Oil Mills

When the priority is to obtain the maximum profit, good environmental management and ease, efficiency and stability of production as an option, then utility matters at the palm oil mill may be collaborated with other parties. This specialization becomes important because of the priority choices above. The utility problems in question are electricity and steam. Electricity is produced from a steam turbine and steam is produced from a boiler. High pressure steam enters the steam turbine to drive a generator and produce electricity and low pressure steam output from the steam turbine is used for the fresh fruth bunch (FFB) sterilization process. Water treatment for boiler feed is also part of the utility problem, as well as for boiler operations to produce output in the form of electricity and steam.

Regarding cooperation or business models, palm oil mills can pay for the electricity and steam they receive. But because the fuel or energy to produce electricity and steam comes from palm oil mills, of course the price is cheaper. If currently almost all palm oil mills use their boiler fuel from mesocarp fiber and palm kernel shell (PKS), then with this specialization it is possible for palm fiber (mesocarp fiber) and empty palm fruit bunches (EFB) to be used as fuel or energy sources while palm kernel shells (PKS) can 100% sold and even exported. Palm kernel shells (PKS) as biomass fuel can be sold directly and are in great demand, and are also the main competitor for wood pellets in the global biomass fuel market.

Under these conditions, there are efforts to increase the efficiency of utility production such as steam and electricity as optimally as possible, not only combustion technology with static grates, moving grates, reciprocating grates to fluidized beds, but it is even possible to use pyrolysis. EFB or empty palm fruit bunches, which were previously unprocessed and were an environmental problem, can become a potential energy source so that 100% of the palm kernel shells / PKS from palm oil mills can be commercialized/sold. And even if the utility provider uses pyrolysis, biochar will also be obtained. Biochar provides many benefits related to soil fertility and climate.