The Urgency of Biochar Application on Palm Oil Plantations in Indonesia

The large number of acidic soils in Indonesia that are used for palm oil plantations makes the productivity of palm oil fruit or the resulting FFB (fresh fruit bunch) not optimal. The acid soil covers the largest dryland area in Indonesia. It occupies approximately 55% of the total land area (191.09 million ha) in Indonesia. About 107.36 million ha of all Indonesian acid soils is classified as dryland acid soils and the rest (14.93 million ha) as peat soil. Acid soils in Indonesia are distributed amongst the big islands, such as Kalimantan (39.42%), Sumatera (28.81%), Papua (18.03%), Java (7.77%), and Sulawesi (6.95%). Acidic soils with low pH make nutrient absorption low in plants and so do soil microbial activity, which plays a large role in soil fertility. This condition should not be ignored because besides making the cultivation of palm oil plantations not optimal, there will also be a lot of fertilizer used. This makes the operational costs of  palm oil plantation operation high. Biochar is a biomass pyrolysis product that is effective and efficient in overcoming these problems. With the abundant amount of biomass waste produced by palm oil mills or CPO mills as biochar raw materials, efforts to improve the quality of plantation soil should be easy to do and have even become the operational standard for these plantations. But the fact is not.

 

Why hasn't biochar been used to improve soil quality and thus increase the production of palm oil fruit or FFB? The lack of information and education about the benefits and uses of biochar are the main factor. This of course makes the application of biochar in palm oil plantations not yet done even though palm oil mills have abundant biomass waste such as empty palm fruit bunches (EFB) and fiber which are generally not used and cause environmental problems. The priority for processing EFB compared to other products such as EFB pellets or compost also needs separate considerations. The best choice, of course, is based on a comprehensive study according to the characteristics of the business or business will be built. Consider not only short-term economic benefits, but also environmental and long-term benefits is an important thing.

Quantitatively, an increase in the production of palm oil fruit or FFB, an increase of at least 20% with the application of biochar is something that is normal. And a 20% increase in fruit production will also result in a big profit. Productivity of a number of other agricultural commodities can be increased by 30%, 40% or even more than 100%. The low productivity of palm oil fruit in Indonesia can be increased by the application of biochar, which is particularly effective in improving the soil quality in the palm oil plantations. Moreover, about 80% of the components of the cost of producing crude palm oil (CPO) come from the plantations, and 20% in the processing sector (palm oil mills). The operational costs of palm oil mill plantations, especially fertilizers, can also be reduced by the use of biochar. The priority of liquid biofuel development will also get better if the volume of biofuel raw materials such as CPO increases. This shows the strategic role of biochar. Apart from that from the aspect of climate change, biochar will also absorb CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere or reduce the concentration of greenhouse gases, as a solution to today's world problems. 

 

Meanwhile, from the side of the palm oil mill, another advantage obtained from biochar production is the use of excess energy from the pyrolysis process or the production of biochar as an energy source for the boiler. Boiler feed water (BFW) will also be preheated twice when it is used for cooling in the pyrolysis condenser and then the economizer on the boiler. In this way, the energy needed by the boiler decreases. When the boiler energy source uses the energy source from pyrolysis, this means that the palm kernel shell (PKS) can be taken and used for other things and can even be sold directly for local and export markets. The main obstacle to business development in the palm oil industry is the availability of energy source namely electricity. If the energy source is available, the development of palm oil-based businesses is very open and varied, such as the production of CPO derivatives, palm kernel shell processing, PKO production, PKO derivative production, biomass power plants and so on.

Planning Long-Term Feed Supply

Feed is the highest cost component in animal husbandry with a share of about 70%. Thus, feed has an important role for the sustainability of the business. Planning in the provision of good feed will reduce the risk of failure, including a decrease in the production of these farms. Maintaining the high performance of the livestock industry is not an easy thing, of course, including maintaining the quality and quantity of the feed. Feed planning for long-term supply needs to be done carefully and comprehensively so that livestock business can be optimal. Seasonal factor is an important factor in the availability of the feed. The success rate and the amount of profit earned can also be predicted better.

In commercial business, ruminant feed, especially sheep, goats and cattle, is generally easier to obtain than poultry or chicken feed. Imports of soybean meal have been carried out for the poultry or chicken feed. Chicken meat is still ranked 1st as a source of animal protein in Indonesia with a portion of around 70%. Whereas for the ruminants above, generally the feed can be provided by local food sources such as grasses and legume plants. But along with the narrowing of the land that can be used for forage crops, the more limited the availability of feed for livestock, especially for pasture. This condition makes it difficult for ruminant farms to be developed in large capacities or industry-oriented. Energy plantations with an area of up to thousands of hectares are expected to be a solution for this.

The development of energy plantations itself is closely related to the use of renewable energy, especially biomass, both locally / domestically and globally. In line with the bioeconomy era, the use of fossil fuels as well as for the manufacture of various other products is reduced, so biomass will receive more attention and will be increasingly used. This should be in line with the growth of the ruminant livestock sector and the halal industry in general. Related to animal feed, there are 3 important things that need to be considered, namely nutrition, safety and sustainability. Apart from these factors, technological, logistics and good management factors also play an important role in the long-term sustainability of the feed supply. If all the elements of feed (fiber, protein, vitamins, minerals, etc.) can be fulfilled from local / domestic sources so that the price is cheaper, the livestock business will be more competitive. Meanwhile, if it depends on imports, the cost of feed will be expensive and the livestock business will be less competitive so that the output of meat and milk products as a source of protein will also be expensive. And don't let the domestic animal feed production grow, say 5 times but imports of raw materials 15 times.

Production of EFB Pellet EFB or EFB Biochar ?

One of the main obstacles for palm oil mills to develop their business is the availability of electricity. With locations that are generally located in remote areas in the middle of palm oil plantations, palm oil mills do not get electricity supply from PLN (Indonesia State Owned Electricity Company). Eventhough electricity is very important in a production process, such as in the production of EFB pellets. Even though empty bunches or EFB in general are an environmental problem for palm oil mills. If every ton / hour of EFB pellet production takes 300 KW, then for production of 10 tonnes / hour (5,000 tonnes / month) 3 MW of electricity is needed, export of biomass fuels such as wood pellets and PKS (palm kernel shell)  with bulk shipments usually requires 10 thousand tons / shipment. So if the production of EFB pellets is planned for 10 thousand tons / month so that every month can export the EFB pellets, the factory capacity or EFB pellet production is 20 tons / hour (10,000 tons / month) 6 MW of electricity is needed. For palm oil mills, utilizing liquid waste or POME to become biogas is a potential source of energy for the production of electricity. However, with a palm oil mill capacity of 30 tonnes of FFB / hour, only about 1 MW of electricity is generated from POME biogas, so to produce 6 MW of palm oil mills with a capacity of 6 x 30 tonnes of FFB / hour are generated equal to 180 tonnes of FFB / hour. In fact, the average palm oil mill has a capacity of 45 - 60 tonnes of FFB / hour, so it is impossible to generate 6 MW of electricity from the palm oil mill's POME biogas.

The use of EFB pellets is the same as wood pellets and PKS is mainly for power generation. All three are biomass fuels. The high chlorine and potassium content in empty palm fruit bunches or EFB makes their use limited to power plants due to corrosion and scale causes. Not all power plants can use EFB pellets at large capacities or quantities. The use of coal-fired power plants with pulverized combustion technology can only be used with a small ratio or an estimate of less than 5%, but can be used more or even 100% in fluidized bed and stoker types of power plants. The capacity of fluidized bed and stoker type PLTU is generally much smaller than pulverized combustion.

When the biomass source is managed properly, the use of biomass fuel is an environmentally friendly and sustainable fuel. Biomass fuels like this are carbon neutral fuels, because they do not increase the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere. This is because the biomass as a fuel source comes from plants whose growth is from the photosynthesis process, one of which uses CO2 from the atmosphere, so that when the biomass is burned, there is practically no addition of CO2 to the atmosphere. In general, there are 2 ways to overcome the CO2 concentration in the atmosphere which causes climate change and global warming, namely the carbon neutral scenario and the carbon negative scenario. In a carbon negative scenario, CO2 in the atmosphere will be captured and absorbed so that it is no longer released and the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere can be reduced, as in the biochar application below.

Whereas in the production of biochar with pyrolysis, besides not requiring a large amount of electrical power for its operation, electricity can also be generated from the use of excess energy from pyrolysis itself. By using the excess energy from pyrolysis, the palm oil mill boiler fuel does not need to use palm kernel shells and fiber. The use of gas or liquid fuels from the excess energy of the pyrolysis process also makes burning emissions cleaner. To achieve more complete combustion, gaseous or liquid fuels are better than solid fuels. Palm kernel shells so that everything can be sold or even exported. The biochar product applied to palm oil plantations will also improve the quality of the soil so that fertilizer use can be reduced and the productivity of palm oil fruit will increase. Biochar also absorbs CO2 from the atmosphere so that the use of biochar in large palm oil plantations means that with massive applications it can also be used for carbon trading. Recent developments indicate that the use of biochar is increasingly widespread, such as biomaterials for construction, transportation, plastics, packaging, furniture and so on. The use of biomaterials for these products means substituting the use of fossil-derived raw materials.

So based on the above review, the production of biochar with pyrolysis is more profitable and easy to implement for palm oil mills compared to EFB pellet production. The addition of electricity production with a large capacity and the availability of sufficient raw materials is not easy and cheap for the average palm oil mill in Indonesia with a capacity of 45 - 60 tons of FFB / hour. Whereas in the production of biochar with pyrolysis, a certain amount of energy is produced which can be used for various purposes and the use of biochar is also multi-beneficial. Palm oil mills should consider this in particular in the aspects of waste management, plantation productivity, environmental aspects and business development, for more read here. Based on experience, the cost structure of the CPO or palm oil production business consists of about 80% of the cost of production is the cost of crops or plantation aspects, while the other 20% is the cost of processing or mill aspects. And the highest cost aspect of palm oil plantations is the cost of fertilization so that if the need for fertilizer can be reduced and the productivity of palm oil can be increased, of course it is very profitable, biochar is effective and efficient to use for this.

Increasing Energy Efficiency in Palm Oil Mill Operations Using Pyrolysis

Energy utilization in the form of steam production which is then used for electricity production through steam turbines and generators, as well as the use of steam for steamming (sterilizing) fresh fruit bunches (FFB) are the main things in palm oil mill operations. This is because the need for electrical energy to power various mechanical equipment in the mill comes entirely from this electricity production. Electricity and steam for industrial processing are grouped under the utilities that support that industry. Meanwhile, in the sterilization process or the boiling of FFB, steam besides stopping the development of FFA (free fatty acid) and facilitating the threshing will also facilitate the CPO extraction process and processing the kernel (palm kernel). To produce steam and electricity, of course, energy is needed, namely heat. Steam is produced by the boiler in the form of superheated steam to drive steam turbines and generators to produce electricity and then steam from electricity production or low pressure steam is used for steamming (sterilization) of FFB.

The water after being treated so that it becomes BFW (boiler feed water) is then used for the production of steam and electricity. Heat energy to produce steam can be reduced in such a way with the use of a pyrolysis process (which means that it is not ordinary combustion), so that the heat requirement for the boiler furnace is getting smaller. The pyrolysis condenser will produce hot water so that it becomes preheating for the boiler. In pyrolysis a condenser is used to separate bioil and syngas (uncondensable gas). Preheating from the condensation process of the pyrolysis unit will then go to stage 2 preheating in the economizer of the boiler unit. Thus the temperature of the water entering the upper drum on the boiler is high enough, and the heat requirement to become superheated steam will be reduced. The palm oil mill uses a water tube type boiler as is commonly used in large industries and not a fire tube which is in the form of a shell and tube type heat exchanger with the tube submerged in water so that it does not overheat. In a water tube type boiler, it consists of an upper and lower drum (mud drum) which is connected to a pipe. The lower drum and water tube are fully filled with water, while the upper drum is only partially filled. With this arrangement, steam will pass through the mechanical separator on the upper drum, flow to the superheater and exit the boiler. Efficiency is the key word in production, including the use of energy in the production process of CPO or palm oil mills. The rule of thumb is an increase of 10 C in BFW is equivalent to increasing 1% boiler efficiency.

Typical of water tube boiler

Excess energy from the pyrolysis process should be used for fuel or energy sources in the boiler furnace. The use of excess energy from pyrolysis will also produce environmentally friendly flue gas emissions because the combustion of liquid and gaseous fuels will be cleaner than solid fuels. In this way, the palm kernel shell, which has been used for boiler fuel, can no longer be used. All these palm kernel shells or PKS can be sold directly and even exported to Japan and Korea. Of course, be a separate source of additional income. Palm kernel shells or PKS are competitors for wood pellets in the global market because they have many similar properties, but because palm kernel shells come from waste or palm oil mill sideproducts, the price can be cheaper, more information can be read here. The use of slow pyrolysis for biochar production is the best option compared to similar technologies such as fast pyrolysis and gasification, more details can be read here. Palm oil mills or companies will get a lot of benefits from biochar production, for more details can be read here.