From Carbon Neutral to Carbon Negative : Development of Batteries, Wood Pellets, Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) and Biochar

Research to develop large capacity batteries continues to be carried out so that electricity produced from renewable energy power plants such as wind and solar can be stored and used at any time. Electricity generation that comes from wind and sun is intermittent, that is, at any time the wind may not blow or there will be thick clouds or at night so there is no sunlight and electricity cannot be produced. In this condition, it is necessary to use a large capacity battery that can store this electricity. It is predicted that the development of this battery will not only require large costs but will also take a long time. It is predicted that it will take several decades for this battery to become a reality.

The current electricity supply, the majority of which still uses fossil fuels, especially coal, which has been proven to be environmentally unfriendly (carbon positive), needs to continue to be reduced and the portion of renewable energy in the form of wood pellets (carbon neutral) added by cofiring. The portion or ratio of cofiring can continue to be increased and can even be 100% using wood pellets (fulfiring). If the coal power plant can be changed 100% to a biomass or wood pellet fueled power plant, the power plant will become environmentally friendly or carbon neutral. And at a time when renewable energy sources are abundant and the electrical energy products can be stored in large capacity batteries, it is possible that power plants using combustion technology could be closed or stopped.

The use of wood pellets can be said to be an intermediate solution before the battery era. Large capacity wood pellet production will ideally use energy plantations as a supplier or source of raw materials. Fast rotation crops and plantations from legume groups such as calliandra and gliricidae are the right choice for these energy plantationns. Energy plantations themselves can act as carbon sinks or absorb CO2 from the atmosphere. With good management so that the volume of biomass or wood harvested is smaller or maximum equal to the plant growth rate, the function of energy plantations as carbon sinks continues to be maintained. Using wood pellets as carbon neutral fuel while managing energy plantations as a carbon sink or negative carbon provides optimal environmental benefits.

 

The use of 100% biomass fuel in power plants is carbon neutral, the same as the use of renewable energy from wind, water and sun. However, the use of biomass energy, especially wood pellets, is not intermittent and is always available when needed. Using batteries will be a solution to the intermittent problem. This 100% biomass fueled power plant can become carbon negative when using CCS (carbon capture and storage) devices. And this is very good because it can return the CO2 emitted into the atmosphere back to the bowels of the earth (carbon negative). And when coal power plants are installed with CCS devices, they will become carbon neutral. However, the CCS device is still very expensive and its operation is also not cheap.

And when the battery era arrives so that electricity generation using combustion technology is closed or stopped, the wood from the energy plantations that have been created will be used as raw material for biochar. It is possible that the wood from these energy plantations is still made into wood pellets to save transportation costs and make handling easier and then taken to pyrolysis facilities for biochar production. Biochar used in agriculture has dual benefits, namely improving soil quality and as a carbon sink. Using biochar with fertilizer will create slow release fertilizer, thereby increasing NUE (nutrient use efficiency) for plants, thereby saving fertilizer costs and reducing environmental pollution. Biochar is able to last or not decompose for hundreds of years or is permanent in the soil. The more biochar used, the more benefits it will provide for soil fertility and climate. Biochar as a carbon sink or carbon sequestration is also carbon negative. Energy plantations with good management will become carbon sinks and the biochar is also a carbon sink in the form of carbon sequestration, of course this provides the most optimal climate benefits.

Coal Companies and New Business Development in Renewable Energy (Wood Pellets and PKS)

Coal is a fossil fuel which is one of the main causes of greenhouse gases, especially CO2, which causes global warming and climate change. Even though this fuel is cheap and available in abundance in Indonesia, its use will be increasingly reduced over time to achieve safe conditions for the earth. Indonesia is the 5th largest coal producer in the world with production of around 570 million tons per year with reserves reaching 38 billion tons, the main production of which is on the islands of Sumatra and Kalimantan. A large coal company in Indonesia can produce 50 million tons of coal every year.

Policies to reduce consumption of fossil fuels, especially coal, also continue to be implemented globally. For Asia, for example, Japan and Korea with their Feed in Tariff and Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) are leading the way in the use of renewable energy, especially wood pellets. Meanwhile in Europe, with the Renewable Energy Directive II (RED II), renewable energy is targeted to reach 32% by 2030, biomass fuel is predicted to reach around 75% of the share of renewable energy and the target is that coal will not be used completely by 2050. Germany has announced that it will not use coal. By 2038, the UK is even targeting no longer using coal for its electricity production starting October 2024. North America, namely the United States and Canada as members of the G7, are also committed to reducing coal consumption, in 2018 Canada even announced regulations to no longer use coal for electricity generation by 2030. On the other hand, coal power plant construction projects funded by China in various countries have collapsed. Plus, the G7 countries (Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, England and the United States) are aggressively blocking the use of coal. Countries that still support coal use, such as China and Indonesia, are increasingly isolated and could face more pressure to stop such activities.

Seeing the world energy trend which is starting to decarbonize, many coal companies are then developing new businesses in the renewable energy sector. A number of coal companies are known to have planned to produce large capacity wood pellets and also become palm kernel shell (PKS) exporters. And seeing the global trend in the use of renewable energy which continues to increase, especially biomass fuel, it is possible that in the near future they will immediately execute this plan. With the large profits from the coal business, developing new businesses should also be easier.

For these coal producers whose business sector is in the energy sector, marketing these biomass fuel products should not be difficult. Wood pellets and palm kernel shells / pks can be used as fuel in power plants just like coal. In fact, a number of coal-fired steam power plants also use certain amounts of biomass fuel which is mixed with coal, namely by cofiring. In fact, biomass fuel can be used 100% in certain types of technological power plants such as stokers and fluidized beds. As both products for energy, more specifically solid fuels with the same users, it is indeed easier for coal companies to develop into the wood pellet industry and export palm kernel shells / pks.

In contrast to palm kernel shells / pks which is waste or by-product from palm oil mills or CPO mills which are obtained by collecting from palm oil mills, wood pellet production for large capacities requires a stable and sustainable supply of raw materials with one of the best options being wood from energy plantation. Energy plantations with a certain area need to be created according to the wood pellet production targets to be achieved. Post-mining land can be reclaimed for energy plantations. And for coal companies developing renewable energy also gives a positive image because it contributes to the decarbonization program and if in time the coal business has to be reduced or even stopped, they will be ready with a new business in the form of renewable energy.

Opportunity to Export Wood Pellet to Germany

At the end of 2022 or this year, all nuclear power plants in Germany will be discontinued, then in 2030 or at the latest in 2038 all coal fired power plants will also be discontinued. Germany in the context of decarbonization has planned to reduce fossil fuels, especially coal in its power plant. The percentage of nuclear power plants in Germany is 3.6% or about 8 GW and this requires immediate efforts to replace the electricity supply. Meanwhile, coal-fired power plants reach about 28% or more than 40 GW, and currently electricity production with coal is very expensive, due to the price of coal itself and carbon tax. Coal prices are around $150 but recently there has been a spike to $435 and a carbon tax of over $100 for every ton CO2 emitted. With these cost components, the price of electricity production for each MWh reaches around $220 (not including labor costs, maintenance, and so on), whereas if it is replaced with wood pellets the production price is only around $90 per MWh or approximately one third. Very cheap. Moreover, with the use of wood pellets, the sulfur scrubbing process (FGD = flue gas desulphurisation) can be reduced or even eliminated.

Biomass fuels such as wood pellets are carbon neutral so they do not increase the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere, so that when using wood pellets for power generation and subsequent CO2 gas emissions, which are greenhouse gases, are captured and stored (CCS = Carbon Capture and Storage) so that they do not escape into the atmosphere, then this becomes carbon negative or reduces the concentration of CO2 in the atmosphere. The amount of CO2 gas that can be captured and soraged can also get carbon credit compensation, so that the coal power plants will get additional income. But without even having to use CCS, the use of wood pellets has reduced the cost of electricity production very significantly and is environmentally friendly. Meanwhile, if the power plant uses coal which is carbon positive and then CO2 emissions are captured and stored with CCS technology, this becomes carbon neutral. Of course, carbon negative efforts are better than carbon neutral.

On the other hand, Germany is famous for its technological products, especially industrial machines. A number of machine manufacturers for the production of wood pellets also come from Germany, such as Muench, Salmatec and Kahl. These machines are widely used for the production of wood pellets around the world and are reliable. It is possible that later the machines for the production of wood pellets will be imported from Germany and wood pellet products from Indonesia will be exported to Germany. This is in accordance with the potential advantages of each country. Indonesia with a land area of 1.91 million km2 with a lot of available land and being in the tropics has great potential as the world's main producer of wood pellets.

Currently about 55% of the fuel for power generation in Germany uses natural gas originating from Russia, and currently war is breaking out between Russia and Ukraine. The issue of Germany's alignment may affect the supply of natural gas from Russia to the country due to the war. Conversion from coal power plant to wood pellet power plant is not difficult and does not require a large investment, so this conversion is the most realistic solution. With the number of coal-fired power plants in Germany more than 100 units or about 1/3 of the electricity supply, so the need for wood pellets will also be very large if the power plants switch to wood pellets.